Google UK boss warns about Bard’s reliability, urges users to cross-check answers

Google UK’s Managing Director Debbie Weinstein has issued a cautionary message to users regarding the reliability of Google’s AI chatbot, Bard. The AI chatbot, launched in February this year, was initially seen as an alternative to conventional search engines, including Google’s own search engine. However, Weinstein emphasized that Bard is still a work in progress […]

Follow us:

Google UK’s Managing Director Debbie Weinstein has issued a cautionary message to users regarding the reliability of Google’s AI chatbot, Bard. The AI chatbot, launched in February this year, was initially seen as an alternative to conventional search engines, including Google’s own search engine. However, Weinstein emphasized that Bard is still a work in progress and may not always provide trustworthy answers, and urged users to cross-check Bard’s responses using the traditional Google search engine to ensure accuracy and reliability.

During an interview with the news outlet BBC, Weinstein acknowledged that Google is aware of the trust users place in the search engine for accurate and reliable information. She emphasized that Bard is not the ideal source for finding ‘specific information’, stating that users should continue to rely on Google’s traditional search engine for that purpose.

This is not the first time concerns have been raised about Bard’s reliability. In April, financial news outlet Bloomberg reported that an internal document revealed 18 current and former Google employees expressing concerns about Bard’s provision of low-quality information. The report suggested that Google was ‘in a race to keep up with the competition’, giving ‘less priority to its ethical commitments’.

Google Bard workers underpaid, overworked; competition with OpenAI blamed

More recently, those responsible for training Bard have come forward to express their dissatisfaction with working conditions. Contract workers said that they were overworked, underpaid, and stressed while reviewing Bard’s answers, as per the report by Bloomberg.

The workload and complexity of tasks reportedly increased due to competition with OpenAI, the makers of another popular AI tool ChatGPT. Workers without adequate training were asked to verify answers on diverse subjects such as medicine and law. The review process involved tight deadlines, sometimes as little as three minutes, to evaluate Bard’s responses.

One contractor conveyed, “As it stands right now, people are scared, stressed, underpaid, and don’t know what’s going on.”

“And that culture of fear is not conducive to getting the quality and the teamwork that you want out of all of us,” the contractor added.

In addition to these concerns, a Google contract worker expressed worries to the US Congress via a letter in May, warning that Bard could become a ‘faulty and dangerous product’ due to the tight deadlines imposed on contractors, who were paid as little as US$14 per hour to review content.