What does PM Modi’s Ukraine visit say to Russia? Moscow's bond with Beijing vs Delhi's dance with DC

Ukraine insists that Russian troops must vacate its territory before any negotiations can begin. Conversely, Russia has declared several Ukrainian regions as part of its territory, making any mediation effort unlikely in the near future.

Author
Top Indian News Desk
Follow us:

PM Narendra Modi and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy (ANI)

New Delhi: Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent visit to Ukraine marks a significant moment in global geopolitics, signaling India’s strategic balancing between major powers. As his first visit to Ukraine since the country gained independence, this diplomatic engagement comes on the heels of a recent visit to Russia, where Modi was warmly received by President Vladimir Putin. The visit symbolizes India's careful dance of neutrality amid the escalating Russia-Ukraine war and the shifting dynamics of global power.

A balancing act?

India's foreign policy under Modi has consistently focused on strategic autonomy, refusing to be swayed by the West or any singular power bloc. Modi’s hug with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is now being seen as a counterweight to the much-debated embrace with Putin just weeks earlier. The visit illustrates India’s message to the world: its relationship with Russia and Ukraine are not mutually exclusive.

At a time when the West is wary of India’s continued ties with Russia—especially amid sanctions—Modi’s visit to Ukraine highlights India's balancing act. India has always maintained a neutral stance on the Russia-Ukraine conflict, refraining from condemning Moscow outright but calling for a peaceful resolution and respect for territorial integrity.

Strengthening bilateral cooperation

The visit is not just about optics. Modi's meetings with Ukrainian officials signal deeper intentions to strengthen bilateral ties in defense, economic relations, science, and technology. India, looking to diversify its supply chains and reduce reliance on Russia, engaged in delegation-level discussions aimed at boosting cooperation across these sectors.

Ukraine, which hosts a significant Indian student diaspora, remains a vital trade partner for India. With bilateral goods trade at $3.4 billion in FY22, Ukraine ranks among India’s top 50 trading partners. Moreover, Ukraine has been a key source of defense technology and spare parts—an important relationship for India's transition to self-reliance in defense manufacturing.

India’s neutral role in the Russia-Ukraine conflict

India's measured response to the Russia-Ukraine war has garnered both criticism and praise. While New Delhi has refused to cut ties with Moscow, its increasing engagement with Western powers—particularly the US—underscores its strategic diversification. Russia remains a key supplier of defense hardware and energy to India, but India has gradually reduced its dependence on Russian imports.

India’s oil purchases from Russia, even amid sanctions, have been scrutinized by Western nations. However, India continues to assert its independent foreign policy, pursuing national interests while maintaining crucial ties with both Russia and the West.

Growing influence of Russia-China ties

Modi's visit also reflects concerns over the warming relations between Russia and China. The formation of an informal bloc between Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea could counter Western influence in the global power struggle. India is keenly aware of this alignment and is determined to maintain strategic independence without alienating either side.

Russia, which has traditionally been India’s most reliable defense partner, now shares deeper ties with China, raising concerns in New Delhi. India’s foreign policy aims to keep Russia close while deepening its relations with the West, ensuring it is not caught in the crosshairs of any major power conflict.

US-India relations: A growing partnership

India’s relationship with the United States continues to strengthen across various sectors, including defense, technology, and economic ties. India and the US share mutual concerns over China’s aggressive posturing in the Indo-Pacific region. This has led to enhanced military cooperation and bilateral trade, positioning the US as a key partner in India’s broader geopolitical strategy.

India's ability to foster strong relationships with both Russia and the US demonstrates its adeptness in maintaining a fine balance in an increasingly multipolar world.

Diplomacy on tightrope

Modi’s visit to Kyiv signals India's growing involvement in the global political stage without taking sides. This diplomatic tightrope shows India’s commitment to multi-partnerships in a complex world order. Modi's government has frequently emphasized India’s ability to engage with all global powers, navigating the complexities of their national interests.

While Zelensky may have expressed discomfort with India’s recent overtures toward Russia, Modi reassured him of India’s peace-driven stance in the ongoing conflict. For India, Europe represents an essential partner in trade and security, further driving the significance of this visit.

Can India emerged as a potential peace mediator?

Speculation about India’s role as a mediator between Russia and Ukraine has circulated for some time, given its cordial relationships with both nations. However, India remains cautious, aware of the complexities involved and the lack of concrete steps towards peace from either side. While Modi has advocated for a peaceful resolution through diplomacy, India has refrained from directly intervening.

Ukraine insists that Russian troops must vacate its territory before any negotiations can begin. Conversely, Russia has declared several Ukrainian regions as part of its territory, making any mediation effort unlikely in the near future.

A symbolic gesture to the West

For Western nations, Modi’s visit to Kyiv signals that India is willing to engage with Ukraine and, by extension, the West. This gesture helps India avoid potential isolation or sanctions that may arise from its close ties with Russia. However, some Western analysts suggest that the visit is more symbolic than substantive, designed to reaffirm India’s strategic autonomy and position itself as a global player.

Priortizing national interest above all 

Domestically, Modi’s Kyiv visit is seen as a move to further India’s strategic interests. By maintaining ties with all major powers, Modi projects an image of India as a global leader that prioritizes its national interests above all else. The visit underscores India's drive to reduce dependency on any single nation or power bloc.

India’s declining imports of Russian weapons and its pivot towards partners such as the US, France, and Israel highlight a broader strategy of diversification. This shift is part of India’s effort to enhance its self-reliance and assert its strategic autonomy on the global stage.

What does the future hold?

Modi’s visit to Ukraine is a statement in itself, symbolizing India’s willingness to engage with all sides of the conflict while maintaining its neutrality. While the visit may not result in significant immediate changes in India’s relationships with Russia or Ukraine, it reaffirms India’s position as a balanced player in global geopolitics.

Looking ahead, one area of potential cooperation could be in the reconstruction of Ukraine post-conflict. India, with its experience in Afghanistan, could play a significant role in rebuilding efforts once peace is restored. However, for now, Modi’s visit serves as a reminder that India’s foreign policy is driven by its national interests, and it will continue to walk the tightrope of diplomacy with great skill.